Austin Beutner is co-founder of Evercore, author of Proposition 28, founder of Vision to Learn and formerly head of Los Angeles Unified School District schools and First Deputy Mayor of the City of Los Angeles.
Ben Franklin helped establish what is now the oldest continuously operating property insurance company, founded on a remarkable principle: Property insurance should serve the public good, not simply private profit.
That stands in sharp contrast to the current situation. According to data from the credit rating firm AM Best, in the first half of 2026 U.S. property and casualty insurers tripled underwriting profits compared to the same period last year. Unsurprisingly, nearly half of claims were closed without payment.
In California, premiums paid by homeowners increased 112% between 2017 and 2025 while insurers continued to deny valid claims and the state’s insurance commissioner, Ricardo Lara, traveled the world on junkets paid for by the very industry he was supposed to oversee. Meanwhile, Lara’s former special counsel now works for a law firm that represents the insurance industry.
Golden State is a reader-supported nonprofit publication. Help us remain independent with a tax-deductible donation.
My family is living with the consequences of this misconduct.
Like many others, our home survived the flames of the 2025 Palisades fire but was consumed by smoke, ash and other toxins. Chubb, our insurer, hired an environmental consulting firm to evaluate the damage and assured us in an email, “They know exactly what to look for… and will test everything.”
That was a lie.
Chubb did not test for the toxic heavy metals such as arsenic, lead, lithium and others that are known by-products of urban wildfires. The consultant’s report said “hidden conditions may exist” at our home, yet they did not test the roof, attic or interior cavities of the walls, claiming those areas were “outside of their scope of work.” They concluded by saying they are “not licensed to provide human health risk analyses.”
We hired independent experts. Their testing found extremely high levels of toxic metals, including almost 2,000 times the level of lead the federal government deems acceptable, as well as chromium, lithium and other fire-related contaminants. They told us our home is an “uninhabitable health hazard.”

Chubb has spent nearly two years concocting absurd excuses and proposing knowingly incomplete remediation plans to avoid responsibility. “Lithium was present in the earth’s crust long before it was used in batteries,” they claimed in a specious attempt to explain why it is in my house. They proposed to fix only some of the rooms despite knowing others also contain toxins. Despite the documented contamination, Chubb refuses to repair the roof because it is “not habitable space.” The net of all of this, Chubb has offered less than 25% of the amount experts say it will cost to restore the home to its pre-fire condition.
Companies like Chubb are fighting valid claims and trying to keep the truth about toxic smoke contamination under wraps until the statute of limitations for claims for many policyholders expires on Jan. 7.
The most important responsibility California’s elected insurance commissioner has is to ensure companies abide by the law.
Jane Kim will be sworn in as California’s new insurance commissioner on Jan. 4. She can start working as an advocate for the victims of the 2025 wildfires before then by asking that Los Angeles county and city officials ensure homeowners, renters and workers in Altadena and Pacific Palisades know their rights under California law. These include asking insurers to properly test their property for the presence of toxins like lead, lithium and chromium – including in wall cavities, HVAC systems and attics.
Once she takes office, the Department of Insurance should require all insurance companies to provide data within 30 days on the status of the 13,000 smoke-damage claims from the 2025 fires. Those who do not comply, or are found in violation of the promises they made to policyholders, should be referred to the state attorney general for prosecution.
These immediate actions are necessary to start rebuilding trust in the insurance system. The irresponsible actions of insurers in response to one of the largest and most costly disasters in modern California history cannot go unchallenged.

Kim should then turn her attention to developing a plan to fix California’s insurance system so that it better serves the public. This won’t be simple, but any plan should include the following components:
Reform the claims process
Filing an insurance claim is overly complicated, opaque and open-ended. Insurers like Chubb knowingly hire pay-to-play outside consultants to investigate claims, or send 11 different adjusters over the course of years before they settle a claim, as another family experienced after the Palisades fire.
The state should require that claims documents use plain language to explain exclusions, deductibles and procedures, and set clear deadlines for inspections, coverage decisions and payments.
We need a modern, centralized digital claims complaint and enforcement system. Insurers should be required to participate in an independent dispute resolution system.
Sunshine is the best disinfectant
Premiums have soared while consumers remain in the dark about the job insurers are doing. Regular, standardized insurer-conduct reports — made available to the public online — would give people a basis for comparison. Showing premiums relative to the amount of coverage and reporting claims outcomes — including how quickly claims are handled and how much insurers pay — would help consumers make informed choices about which insurer they can trust when disaster strikes.
Lead the nation, instead of trailing it
Customers need more and better insurance options to reduce prices, and that starts by creating a predictable regulatory framework. The U.S. Government Accountability Office ranks California second to last in the nation in handling reviews of insurers rates; it takes 225 days for rate filings to be acted on compared with the nationwide average of 35 days. This closed-door process avoids public scrutiny and leads to higher prices.
Kim should convene experts from around the country to evaluate California’s challenges and opportunities. Whether it is a new, state-run wildfire insurance program or meaningful reform to the existing system, Californians need insurance with lower costs, expanded coverage options and an enforceable guarantee they will be provided with the help they have paid for.
Ben Franklin had it right. A properly functioning insurance market should benefit all, not just the companies seeking to profit. Jane Kim has a unique opportunity to make that a reality.
What do you think? Golden State Report is a public forum. Send your responses for possible publication to forum@golden-state.org.


