> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.golden-state.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# California voters boosted  democracy by closing recall loophole
- URL: https://www.golden-state.org/undemocratic-flaw-fixed-by-california-voters/
- Published: 2026-11-18T15:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-18T15:00:01.000Z
- Description: Proposition 5 was a sensible measure that got rid of a flaw in the state's direct democracy system. Also, the New York Times gets schooled on Los Angeles' real "Eastside" and a reader responds about bike lanes.
- Author: Mariel Garza
- Tags: California governance, Elections

## Hot Take

*By Mariel Garza*

Of all the statewide propositions that passed on Nov. 3, none will do more to support democracy in California than Proposition 5\. (Only Proposition 4 would have done more, had the attempt to end the ban on public campaign financing passed.)

The measure put on the ballot by the state Legislature pulls the rug out from under politically motivated recall attempts. It does this by separating the replacement ballot from the recall election. It’s a procedural change that might sound minor, but it is not. 

[![CTA Image](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/2026/11/first-birthday-cake.jpg)](https://givebutter.com/golden-states-first-birthday?ref=golden-state.org) 

****It’s** ****Golden State Report’s first birthday!**  
 If you enjoy what you’re reading, please consider giving a gift to support a second year of independent, homegrown journalism.

[Donate here ](https://givebutter.com/golden-states-first-birthday?ref=golden-state.org) 

Currently, a recall election has two questions for voters: one to oust the elected official in question and one to select the replacement from a list of candidates. 

The winner of the replacement election is whichever candidate receives the most votes, even if it is well below 50%. That means a governor, state attorney general or state senator could lose a recall election with 49.99% of the vote and be replaced by someone with 45% or 30%, or 24%, or even less! 

This is [fundamentally undemocratic](https://www.golden-state.org/californias-recall-loophole-lets-losers-win/), but it’s a loophole that Republicans have used to try to gain seats they can’t win in regular elections. Remember, Arnold Schwarzenegger first became governor in a recall against then-Gov. Gray Davis in 2003\. And while Schwarzenegger earned more support from voters than Davis, he still had [only a plurality](https://ballotpedia.org/Gray%5FDavis%5Frecall,%5FGovernor%5Fof%5FCalifornia%5F%282003%29?ref=golden-state.org). 

This was likely at the top of the minds of the Republicans who tried several times to qualify a recall against Gov. Gavin Newsom, starting shortly after he took office. They got lucky with one attempt during the pandemic-addled world of 2020, and Californians were forced to endure – and pay for – a recall election in 2021\. Obviously, it failed.

No more of this political theater. From now on, if a governor is recalled in an election, their position will be filled by the lieutenant governor until the next election. 

Voila. No more loophole. 

[Here’s how Jane Kim can restore trust in California’s insurance industryThe next insurance commissioner has a chance to reform the system to help the state's current and future victims of wildfire.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/icon/Golden-State-Logo--1---1--69a7e90e-e704-4675-9247-c38690071e59.jpg)Golden StateAustin Beutner![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/thumbnail/Palisades-Fires-IStock--b78ea10c-cfb4-471e-9eb5-b2cd2ae87468.jpg)](https://www.golden-state.org/heres-how-jane-kim-can-restore-trust-in-californias-insurance-industry/)

## Noted, With Comment 

*By Paul Thornton*

**“Eastside” vs. the real Eastside:** “CRINGE ALERT” – perhaps that’s how the New York Times should start labeling its pieces explaining Los Angeles. That certainly goes for its recent feature touting the city’s “Eastside” hot spots that omitted the Latino neighborhoods in L.A. 's historical Eastside. [Los Angeles Times](https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2026-11-17/guide-to-eastside-los-angeles-2026?ref=golden-state.org) columnist Gustavo Arellano rights this oversight by highlighting local gems in El Sereno, Boyle Heights and other areas ignored by the New York Times.

**The real schools chief:** In November, Californians elected a new superintendent of public instruction who will step into a significantly diminished role, [something we covered in Golden State](https://www.golden-state.org/state-superintendent-gutted-nov3-election/). A newly created commissioner appointed by Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra will oversee public education starting next year; EdSource reporter Diana Lambert [sizes up](https://edsource.org/2026/who-should-californias-first-education-commissioner-be-experts-weigh-in/770522?ref=golden-state.org) the seven most likely candidates for the powerful job. 

**Not the final word on capital punishment:** Prosecutors across California have sued to stop Gavin Newsom’s mass commutation of 548 death sentences to life in prison without parole. Among them is Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer, who [according to Capitol Weekly](https://capitolweekly.net/the-fight-against-newsoms-death-row-commutations/?ref=golden-state.org) has raised the extremely unlikely possibility that some former death-row inmates could eventually be released from prison.

[Not just Nithya Raman: the democratic socialists who swept L.A. racesCandidates backed by DSA-LA won seats on school boards, local city councils and even Congress. Now comes the hard part: governing.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/icon/Golden-State-Logo--1---1--ae0e514e-fe45-4f88-b9fb-b6e528450166.jpg)Golden StateMariel Garza![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/thumbnail/IMG_6027-0790f4e4-5649-4716-a3d4-5e0341b262c1.jpg)](https://www.golden-state.org/not-just-nithya-raman-dsa-la-candidates/)

**No more dark skies?** At the exponential rate satellites are being launched into space, urban dwellers may not be able to escape light pollution by heading to remote mountain locations. [In the San Francisco Chronicle](https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/satellite-sky-light-pollution-yosemite-22516935.php?ref=golden-state.org), seasonal Yosemite ranger Andrew Coval warns that the tech-funded rush to fill low-Earth orbit with satellites and space mirrors could rob humans of their ability to look up at the stars and connect with the universe. 

**Love the state, not its politicians:** [In the California Post](https://nypost.com/2026/11/15/opinion/this-is-why-i-still-live-in-california/?ref=golden-state.org), Jon Fleischman distinguishes between his vast home state that includes Lake Tahoe, Napa Valley, Dodger Stadium and Disneyland, and the elected Democrats governing it. “I don’t blame anyone who has had enough. But I’m staying,” he writes. “I refuse to conflate the people temporarily entrusted with governing California with California itself.”

**Permitting reform’s collateral damage:** Salton Sea-area residents have endured the serious health consequences of living near a drying lake exposing toxic particles to the air they breathe. Now, they’re wary of a bipartisan permitting reform bill in Washington that could fast-track local lithium and geothermal energy projects, [according to High Country News](https://www.hcn.org/articles/salton-sea-communities-push-back-on-bill-to-fast-track-development/?ref=golden-state.org): “The question is whether federal acceleration of projects will break from a historic legacy of environmental harm or leave those same communities — some of the poorest in California — behind to pay the price once again.” 

---

## Readers Respond

[Let Nithya Raman's great biking makeover of L.A. beginAs mayor, Karen Bass and Eric Garcetti were street-safety failures. The incoming mayor can revolutionize bike travel in L.A. with a few ambitious but doable changes.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/icon/Golden-State-Logo--1---1--ea111f7e-228b-4047-8daa-255d7b41ab64.jpg)Golden StatePaul Thornton![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f3/e8/f3e82768-9e80-45b4-abd1-0abc7003c71a/content/images/thumbnail/IMG_8919-6e70b3b4-a176-4ba9-bb1e-06e8d519d2ad.jpg)](https://www.golden-state.org/nithya-raman-biking-makeover-of-los-angeles/)

****This piece prompted the following comment by a reader. It was lightly edited for space.**

> While dedicated bike lanes should be created and promoted, other problems must be addressed first.  
>  
> I live in West Los Angeles and primarily use the bus and Metro rail to get around. Now the city proposes to add bike lanes on Westwood Boulevard, remove one car lane in each direction, add dedicated bus lanes and keep street parking. How is this going to work?   
>  
> Since before the pandemic there has been hardly any police presence or parking enforcement. Drivers have figured out that they can get away with anything. Just this week the city bus I was riding had to dodge several double-parked vehicles. This is not a rare occurrence. Many drivers do not have an inner locus of control. Bicyclists and pedestrians are sitting ducks.  
>  
> I recently attended a meeting with our City Council member, Katy Yaroslavsky. I brought up these concerns to her. I was told that the city has several hundred fewer police now than before.   
>  
> Unless the city hires replacement officers, adding bike lanes without consistent traffic and parking enforcement is a tragedy waiting to happen. We should not install dedicated bike lanes until we have the personnel to enforce traffic and parking codes and to regularly clean and maintain our streets.   
>  
> – Genie Saffren, Los Angeles

**Have an original photo that you think would look great in this newsletter or a comment you would like to share? Send it to** [**forum@golden-state.org**](mailto:forum@golden-state.org)**.**